Planetary Position Effect on Short-Wave Signal Quality

J. H. N E L S O N

AT THE Central Radio Office of RCA Com­

A new approach to an as yet unsolved problem is the observance of planetary effects on trans­

planets held a "multiple of 90 degrees" arrangement

munications, Inc., in

atlantic short-wave radio signals. Correlation

among themselves, the corre­

lower Manhattan, an obser­ over seven years shows that certain planetary lation was more pronounced.

vatory housing a 6-inch re­ arrangements agree well with the behavior These arrangements were

fracting telescope is main­

of short-wave signals.

called "multiple configura­

tained for the observation of

tions" and exist when two

sunspots. The purpose of

planets are at 0 degree with

erecting this observatory in 1946 was to develop a method each other and a third planet is 90 degrees or 180 degrees

of forecasting radio storms from the study of sunspots. After away from them. Also, a multiple exists when two planets

about one year of experimenting, a forecasting system of are separated by 180 degrees with a third planet 90 degrees

short-wave conditions was inaugurated based upon the from each. These multiples are quite common. A more

age, position, classification, and activity of sunspots. uncommon type of multiple is the case where all three

Satisfactory results were obtained, but failure of this system planets are at 0 degree with each other. From the few

from time to time, indicated that phenomena other than cases recorded, this type of multiple shows the least correla­

sunspots needed to be studied. The first article1 by the tion.

author on this subject appeared in March 1951 ; the current Many of the multiples are completed in the space of a

article is in part a review of that article, and in part will few hours, being accompanied by sharp severe signal

submit additional evidence supporting deductions made degradation. At other times, the multiple may take several

at that time.

days to pass, being accompanied by generally erratic

STUDY OF PLANET POSITIONS
CYCLIC variations in sunspot activity have been studied by many solar investigators in the past and attempts were made by some, notably Huntington,2 Clayton,3 and Sanford,4 to connect these variations to planetary influences. The books of these three investigators were studied and their results found sufficiently encouraging to warrant correlating similar planetary interrelationships with radio signal behavior. However, it was decided to investigate the effects of all the planets from Mercury to Saturn* instead of only the major planets as they had done. The same heliocentric angular relationships of 0, 90, 180, and 270 degrees were used and dates when any two or more planets were separated by one of these angles were recorded.

conditions during the period. The time needed to com­ plete the multiple depends on the relative speeds between the three or more planets involved. These multiples show correlation for plus and minus about 5 degrees from the exact arrangements previously mentioned.
Configurations of this type actually can be considered as cycles and when several cycles peak at the same time there should be maximum effects. The records for 1948, 1949, and 1950 indicate that such has been the result. Specific instances are demonstrated in Gases 1 to 9 in Table I. Since consistency of data is of paramount importance in an article of this type, the same cycles between the same three planets have been selected. We may refer to these arrangements as multicycles.
All the close multicycles made between Mercury-Venus-

Investigation quickly showed there was positive correla­ Jupiter were extracted from the records of 1948,1949,1950

tion between these planetary angles and transatlantic

short-wave signal variations. Radio signals showed a Table I. Multicycles Among Planets Affecting Radio Signal

tendency to become degraded within a day or two of

planetary configurations of the type being studied. How­ ever, all configurations did not correspond to signal

Case»

Dates

Time Consumed

Results in Signal Degradation

degradation. Certain configurations showed better corre­ lation than others.

1 2 3

Considerable study was devoted to the most severe

4 5

degradations and led to the discovery that when three

6. , 7

Revised text of a conference paper recommended by the AIEE Subcommittee on Energy Sources and presented at the AIEE Winter General Meeting, New York, N. Y., January 21-25, 1952.

8 9 10

Feb 23/48 Apr 18-22/48 June 19-23/48 Aug 18-21/48 Oct 15/48 Apr 12/49 Oct 6-8/49 Apr 2-5/50 Sept 28-Oct 1/50 Sept 21-23/51

1 day 5 days 5 days 4 days 1 day 1 day 3 days 4 days 4 days 3 days

Severe 23d and 24th Severe 19th to 22d Slight 19th to 22d Slight 19th to 21st Very severe 14th and 15th Very severe 11th to 13th Very severe 7th and 8th Very severe 1st to 6th Very severe 30th to 4th* Extremely severe 20th to 26th**

J. H. Nelson is with RCA Communications, Inc., New York, N. Y. * J. H. Clark of Press Wireless Inc., New York, N. Y., has found that Uranus, Neptune, and Pluto also show correlation. Mr. Clark has been correlating planetary positions and short-wave signal behavior using the methods given in the author's original article.

* A multicycle between Mercury-Earth-Mars came on 5th and 6th. The degradation continued through to October 7. ** Three complete multicycles took place during this period involving Mercury, Venus, Jupiter, Saturn, and Uranus.

MAY 1952

Nelson—Planetary Position Effect on Short Wave

421

(?ô""^>

E<Tb , ito]

Ί ^ < 5 ~ ò oo i 30

9y0

βο

1 " ■' " Ί | tr f 11

Γ
'

70

120

60

130
$P
140

'VENUS

50
- $ o^bc/cTb
40

150 .

30

160.
MERCURY 14Q24')*
170-
180

rSUN

. 20
-îfP IO

190

350

200 </P
210

220

230

240

* DAILY MOTION

250

JUPITER

T j 11 i ii 1111 |'T

260

270

E Q_P

Figure 1. The heliocentric arrangement of Venus, Mercury, and Jupiter on February 23, 1948, which resulted in severe signal degradation on that day and the one following

and correlated with existing radio conditions. Multi­ cycles for these three planets were found in nine cases which are listed in Table I. Case 10 is a triple multicycle that coincided with an extremely severe signal degradation in 1951. The heliocentric arrangements of the planets involved are shown in Figures 1 and 2 for Gases 1 and 10.
Single configurations (one cycle) between only two isolated planets show the least correlation, but often when several single cycles between several isolated planets coincide in time the correlation is quite pronounced. Most of the single cycles, however, do correlate with at least slight signal degradation. Some correlate with severe degradation.

At times, two, and sometimes three, complete multi­ cycles occur in the space of a few days. At other times a multicycle will occur mingled with one or more single cycles between other planets.
Theoretically, if these planetary arrangements do have the effect that correlation indicates, the cycles between the slow planets should have gradual long-term effects establishing an over-all standard. The most degraded periods should come as the faster planets come into cycle with them or among themselves.
Jupiter and Saturn, the largest planets in the solar system, are the most important. Due to their great size and slow motion, they can exercise the predominating

422

Nelson—Planetary Position Effect on Short Wave

ELECTRICAL ENGINEERING

$ (Tòc/Vo

220

L?Q~P VA
Figure 2. The heliocentric arrangement of the five planets shown which resulted in extremely severe signal degradation from September 20 to 26, 1951

influence on the sun for prolonged periods of time and therefore establish an over-all standard of disturbed or quiet conditions. However, the arrangements of the other slow planets can add to or take away from their effectiveness to some extent. Therefore, when Jupiter and Saturn are spaced near any multiple of 90 degrees, we should find the most degraded years with a high per­ centage of the radio disturbances severe.
The year 1951, which was a very degraded year, is an example of this. A slow planet multiple existed between Jupiter, Saturn, and Uranus with Jupiter and Saturn at nearly 180 degrees and Uranus almost 90 degrees from each. This arrangement set a low standard for 1951

and even normally weak cycles between isolated planets showed an effect. The radio disturbances were prolonged and severe. This multiple between these three slow planets permitted a great increase in fast planet multiples and semimultiples. A semimultiple took place each time a fast planet cycled with Jupiter, Saturn, and Uranus successively within a few days. This happened frequently in 1951.
The records indicate that when Jupiter and Saturn were spaced by a multiple of 60 degrees, radio signals were of better quality than when spaced by multiples of 90 degrees. Under such an arrangement there are fewer multicycles. During such years a high percentage of the

MAY 1952

Nelson—Planetary Position Effect on Short Wave

423

single cycles show no important correlation except on the normally weaker circuits. Only the stronger groups of cycles are then accompanied by significant degradation.
It is worthy of note that in 1948 when Jupiter and Saturn were spaced by 120 degrees, and solar activity was at a maximum, radio signals averaged of far higher quality for the year than in 1951 with Jupiter and Saturn at 180 degrees and a considerable decline in solar activity. In other words, the average quality curve of radio signals followed the cycle curve between Jupiter and Saturn rather than the sunspot curve.
When all nine planets of the solar system are considered, we find a great many multicycles and individual cycles which would make correlation very difficult if these cycles were evenly spaced in time. However, the cycles are not evenly spaced, there being a general tendency for the cycles to occur in groups. There are, however, exceptions to this at times.
CONCLUSION
THE AUTHOR chooses to look upon this hypothesis of a planetary-positions effect upon the quality of short­ wave signals as a new approach to the problem and it should be considered as one more tool with which a re-

searcher might work. A tremendous amount of work needs yet to be done.
The correlation found between signal degradations and these planetary arrangements in the past has been suffi­ ciently consistent to indicate that under these arrange­ ments, particularly in the case of multicycles, the planets possibly influence the sun in such a manner as to cause a temporary change in its radiation characteristics. The ionosphere of the earth is apparently particularly sensitive to these changes and reacts accordingly.
By combining planetary indications with solar observa­ tions and a day-to-day signal analysis, a 24-hour fore­ casting system has been developed which averaged close to 85 per cent accuracy throughout 1950 and 1951 as reported by RCA Communications at Riverhead, L. I., N. Y.
REFERENCES
1. Shortwave Radio Propagation Correlation With Planetary Positions, J. H. Nelson. RCA Review (Princeton, N. J.), March 1951.
2. Earth and Sun (book), E. Huntington. Yale University Press, New Haven, Conn., 1923.
3. Solar Relations (book), H. Clayton. Clayton Weather Service, Canton, Mass., 1943.
4. Influence of Planetary Configurations Upon the Frequency of Visible Sunspots (book), F. Sanford. Smithsonian Institution, Washington, D. C , 1936.

Application of Motors to Household Refrigeration Compressors

L. G. P A C K E R
MEMBER AIEE

THE FIRST mechanical compressor for house­

Modern refrigeration demands a motor-com­ pressor unit of long life, which will operate

development of the hermeti­ cally sealed unit into which

hold refrigeration con­ over long periods with little or no attention was assembled the pump,

sisted of a pump which was

with high efficiency. To achieve this end, the

motor, refrigerant, and oil.

belt-driven by an electric designer of the hermetically sealed motors This design made it possible

motor. There were shaft

used today must take into consideration a

to eliminate belt, shaft, and

seals in the pump to prevent

number of factors peculiar to this application.

seal, and thus provide more

the refrigerant and oil from

space in the box for food per

escaping. The belt and shaft

unit area of floor space. Less

seals were troublesome. Manufacturers did their best to maintenance is required because of elimination of the belt

make as good a box, and the mechanism as quiet, efficient, and shaft seal and by sealing all working parts. The com­

and free of vibration, as was possible at that time. How­ plete unit is also quieter, has less vibration, and can be

ever, with all its shortcomings, the housewife welcomed manufactured at a lower cost than the belt-driven unit.

this type of refrigeration in preference to the old ice box. The hermetically sealed unit is a mechanical, electrical,

One major step in solving these problems was the and chemical unit which poses many problems, and which

has taxed the ingenuity of mechanical, electrical, chemical,

Essential text of paper 52-69, "Application of Motors to Household Refrigeration Compressors," recommended by the AIEE Committee on Domestic and Commercial Applications and approved by the AIEE Technical Program Committee for presenta­ tion at the AIEE Winter General Meeting, New York, N. Y., January 21-25, 1952. Scheduled for publication in AIEE Transactions, volume 71, 1952. L. C Packer is with the Westinghouse Electric Corporation, Springfield, Mass.

metallurgical, welding, manufacturing, and tool engineers. Today, as a result of their co-operation, the industry can point with pride to the great progress made in the art of making hermetically sealed refrigerators for the household,

424

Packer—Household Refrigeration Compressors

ELECTRICAL ENGINEERING